The Results Are In!
Girl Scout vs The Other Guy
By The Campus Eye staff
The Campus Eye staff would like to send out a big THANK YOU to those that participated in our ultimate cookie taste test. We had a lot of fun setting it up and eating the cookies!
The results were a bit surprising, with Wal Mart’s Great Value brand bring home the most votes in 2 out of the 3 cookie variety’s.
Samoa – Chocolate, caramel and fudge cookie
Variety’s offered:
Wal Mart – Great Value, Keebler, Aldi – Benton’s, Girl Scout
The Winner Is…
Girl Scout
The Girl Scout was the clear winner in this battle with 28 votes. Keebler was 2nd with 18, Aldi – Benton’s was 3rd with 14 and Wal Mart – Great Value came up last with 10.
Thin Mint – Fudge mint cookie
Variety’s offered:
Wal Mart – Great Value, Keebler, Girl Scout
The Winner Is…
Wal Mart – Great Value
Wal Mart – Great Value took this one home with 22 votes in a surprising upset! Keebler and Girl Scout tied with 14 votes each.
Tagalong – Fudge covered peanut butter cookie
Variety’s offered:
Wal Mart – Great Value, Girl Scout
The Winner Is…
Wal Mart – Great Value
Wal Mart – Great Value won this round as well with 26 votes in a very close battle. Girl Scout fell 3 shy with 23. This was perhaps the most surprising as the two variety’s had a noticeable difference. The Wal Mart – Great Value cookie had a chocolate cookie base while the Girl Scout cookie had a shortbread base.
The people have spoken! Girl Scouts… Keep an eye on your cookies, you’ve got some competition!
